23 Comments
User's avatar
Helen Cuadra's avatar

Hi Kazu,

Thank you so much for pointing me to this essay; I hadn’t read it yet, and it gave me a lot to reflect on. I’m still in the early stages of experimenting more fully with the Gift Economy in my own work, and the part about vulnerability to ask for what we need really resonates as a growth edge for me.

I also loved the framing of reciprocity as relationship rather than transaction; it helps me see how generosity can ripple through a larger ecosystem of care and trust.

If you’re curious, I just published an essay about my own journey into the Gift Economy and generosity in action: https://holdingcomplexity.substack.com/p/the-gift-of-enough. I’d be delighted to hear your thoughts!

Chas's avatar

Kazu, just discovered your work from Bioneers educational link. I’m working on founding a new nonprofit and trying to work through issues relating to fees and gift economy and much else. Looking forward to reading more of your work and putting it out to the universe that I’d be delighted to meet you at some point. Your work is inspiring and is helping me move through questions and concerns I have. Thank you

Kazu Haga's avatar

Hey Chas thanks so much! Look forward to connecting!

Abbey von Gohren's avatar

The French have one word for “dear” and “expensive”- cher- something about this feels right to me and an alternative to the emptied meaning of “free” that you so eloquently trace here, Kazu. Thank you!

Tom Quinn's avatar

A related conditioning effect of capitalist thinking is the winning-losing duality. If I get something for free, I (very temporarily) feel like "I win!" But because everything is commodified in the capitalist value system, I may lose interest in that "free" thing when the dopamine hit of winning dissipates.

Carol Norris's avatar

This is a lovely share. Thank you.

I've been talking a lot to a pal about this. The Gift Economy speaks to his heart. He's "disabled" with a chronic illness, and worries that he wouldn't be able to offer any "meaningful," concrete reciprocity. Any thoughts?

Adam Wilson's avatar

Greetings Kazu, I am grateful to have found your work. I find this concept one of the most difficult to illuminate in my work with gift economics. I look forward to following your work. Thank you for putting this out into the world.

-Adam Wilson

Kathryn Edwards's avatar

Dear Adam,

Thank you for referencing this excellent piece in your newsletter. So helpful. They say it’s lonely and draughty being a pioneer…

Kazu Haga's avatar

Thank you for reading Adam!

Suzanne Angela's avatar

This was really helpful. I recently let someone borrow a musical instrument for more than a year and when I asked them to return it, they begged to have it longer, which I caved for a while, but eventually they didn’t return it when we had agreed that they would and even asked if they could have it longer. I ended up sending a very curt email and when they called to apologize, I ended up crying because they wanted it still longer and they just weren’t getting my no until they heard me crying. I felt like they were really using me. But you explain how they didn’t know enough about me which is true. In this case, it really wasn’t the money it was worth, it was the value of a fine instrument that I have treasured.

Roshni Robert's avatar

This is me with everything! As soon as the mutual-ness of the exchange is warped, I just get broken. Once I feel taken advantage of I lose my mind. I read about my enneagram 9 personality recently and it described this perfectly as coming from a place of giving all the time and eventually getting maxed out, getting sad or angry or depressed. At that point I don’t even know my own needs anymore!! And I think it’s true, it’s because people need to know about who you or I am to even know how to process the gift!! I hope I can implement this in some way.

Casper ter Kuile's avatar

Wonderfully insightful. Thank you!

Charles Huschle's avatar

Your subtle linking of the "gift" of the books, to how much they cost you to produce, is interesting (do you think the recipients felt a little guilty in taking the books?). That's not a straightforwardly generous or honest gift, unless I've missed the context. Real gifts are given without the hint or expectation of some reward in return. (And, "Donations are freely accepted" of course!)

Kathryn Edwards's avatar

Dear Charles,

As someone else who is also struggling to experiment effectively with ‘gift economy’ reciprocity, I find the innocence of your response really illuminating. It shows how alien the language of the gift economy really is, if we can confuse gift-economy-as-reciprocity with gift-as-spontaneous-present.

Helpful! Thank you!

Kazu Haga's avatar

Hey Charles, thanks for reading, and for the comment. The way I engage with the Gift continues to be an experiment, and therefore far from a perfect system. The reason I share how much the books cost me is because in my understanding, having information about the needs of the giver is a key aspect of the Gift. It's this information that provides enough data for the relationship to become more real. This is something I learned from the person who first taught me about the Gift Economy well over a decade ago.

In my experience, because we are so acculturated to a different system, without this information it can actually make people anxious, as they have no information to base their decision on. Should I give? How much should I give? Is the giver's needs already met? Is the giver in dire need of more generosity?

A principle I love is that in a Gift system, resources flow from where they are to where they are needed. Little bits of information can help everyone figure out where the needs are.

And again, not a perfect system since we are trying to build a bridge between where we are and where we want to be, so I welcome your thoughts!

Krista Savio (she/her)'s avatar

The first discussion about gift economy I came across was “Sacred Economics” by Charles Eisenstein. While in don’t find all his work resonate, something stirred in me with that book, especially the final section about implementation. That section dealt with the current capitalist framework but didn’t articulate what you’re saying here, and what you’re sharing here is such a critical concept. As a point of evidence, the word in ‘Ōlelo Hawai‘i for “free” (in the sense of not costing anything) is “manuahi”. The story behind that word is that there was a kanaka who would give everything away whose name was Manuahi. So the word for giving things away without cost became manuahi. But, of course, this word only came into existence after subsistence economy (in which mutuality was a central tenant) was largely supplanted by a cash-based (capitalist) economy.

Kazu Haga's avatar

I love that, thank you for sharing!!! I'll have to look into that more!

Krista Savio (she/her)'s avatar

I will DM you a picture of the entry for “manuahi” in the Puke Wehewehe ‘Ōlelo Hawai‘i a me Pelekania (The Hawaiian-English dictionary). I heard the story of Manuahi (the person) orally but it’s nice to have written sources sometimes. Also, the definition also talks about how manuahi can also mean “adulterous”, another colonial import. So interesting to see the connections made in the ‘Ōiwi mind about how the imposition of the cash economy alongside monogamous, heteronormative marriage are linked!

Adriana DiFazio's avatar

Kazu, thank you so much for sharing so openly. I'm so inspired by your work and the application of a gift economy. It's making me reconsider different aspects about how I go about building a livelihood. Thank you for modeling what's possible.

Tricia's avatar

Thank you for sharing your thoughts and experience. Maybe it wouldn’t have made a difference, but I’m thinking as someone with ADHD and anxiety that I would have been unlikely to approach you to find out how to donate. It’s too many steps and I would have overthought it to an embarrassing degree. I’d likely scan a qr code or follow other written directions

Kazu Haga's avatar

Hi Tricia, Thank you so much for sharing your experience, and I'm sorry if the way I do things increased your anxiety in any way! This continues to be an ongoing experiment for me, so its far from perfect and I learn more the more I can get feedback about people's experience. Would it be supportive if I also offered a QR code in future events, and perhaps even on my website? Please feel free to let me know what would feel supportive, I am really curious to know! Thank you for the feedback!!!

Tricia's avatar

No need to apologize! I don’t know what other people do, but I think it’s a good idea to have options for people be able to access

Kazu Haga's avatar

Thank you so much Adriana!